18 Jul

more music scams…

last year, I wrote about some scams where people claimed to be looking for music lessons for their son or daughter.

So far, I have not had one single student for guitar come to me through email or the Internet. Every single request has been a scam.

Here is an example email I received today from andrewbarton67@yahoo.com (Andrew Barton):


I’m Andrea Barton during my search for a Music Instrument Lessons teacher that would always take my Daughter (Gwyn) and I found your advert.Your advert looks great and it is very okay to me since you specialize in the area I am seeking for her. My daughter will be coming to your Country before the middle of July for 2 Months. She is just 15yrs Old, a beginner, I want you to help me teach her music during her stay in the Country because i will not want her to less busy, i want her to engage in something to keep her busy during her stay.

So, kindly let me know your charges cost per week in order for me to arrange for the payment before she travels down to your country.I would also like to know if there is any Text Book you will recommend for her as a beginner so that she will be reading privately at home after the lesson during her stay.

Please Advise back on;

(1) Your charges per 1 hour twice a week for 2 Months?

(2) The Day and time you will be available to teach her During the week?

(3) Tuition address?

I will be looking forward to read from you soonest.

Best Regards.

There are a few things about this which should immediately strike anyone:

  • People don’t usually mis-spell their own name. Is it Andrea (in the text) or Andrew (in the email address)?
  • There is no mention of what instrument the girl is supposed to be learning. Guitar? Piano? Didgeridoo?
  • The weird capitalisation says to me that translation software has been used, and only for some specific words. I can imagine a template that goes something like this: “I’m ________ during my search for a ________________ teacher that would always take my ________ (____) and I found your advert”. Every one of the blanked out words was inserted with capital letters.
  • There’s a lot of talk about countries – “your Country”, “the Country”, “down to your country”. This person obviously does not know what country I am in, yet knows that his/her daughter will be coming to it?
  • As for that, “My daughter will be coming to your Country before the middle of July for 2 Months.” The email arrived at 2 in the morning today. It’s the 18th of July. A real request for upcoming lessons would surely arrive weeks or months before the trip had already started?

There is a quirky little urge in me to take this as far as I can. However, I’m also not made of time, so I won’t bother.

So here’s the warning: NEVER trust an email from anyone you don’t know.

Here’s how this would pan out if I took it seriously:

  1. We agree price and dates.
  2. They send a cheque and urge me to cash it. I go to the bank and do so.
  3. I suddenly receive an urgent email saying there’s been an error and they sent me too much, and to please send back the extra money.
  4. Of course, that involves me writing and sending a cheque of my own.
  5. They then cash my cheque.
  6. Their cheque then bounces….
  7. The student never turns up.

So don’t be an idiot. Either throw these email in the spam directory (or delete it), or have fun trying to get the guy to do ridiculous things, but never take it seriously.

Btw: here’s an example of this same exact person being a bit over enthusiastic with the attempts – 9 copy/paste messages, with two separate daughters, Rita and Marsha – this guy should probably have got the kids lessons when they were younger…

3 thoughts on “more music scams…

  1. I replied to the email with this text:

    it’s the 18th of July right now. looks like you were too late this time…


    just got a reply back:

    Thanks for your concern. Could you get back to me with your total cost for the lesson.

    I’ve replied:

    Lessons cost €20 per half-hour. I can teach Maracas, Comb Harmonica or Triangle. I also do grades in each.

    I don’t recommend any more than two lessons per week.

    Which instrument does she want to learn?


  2. We just got the same scam offer through our acting school’s central e-mail address from “Andrea”. What they asked us to do is to accept/cash a check for more than our enrollment and registration fees, take those out, then write a check for the difference for her “daughter’s caretaker” here in the States. I called the cops for guidance and they said we should just write a message indicating that we wouldn’t accept such a check. The detective said that if a check does show up that you should call the cops.

  3. I received a similar letter now almost a year later so I googled this person and music lessons and found your site. Here is the letter I received and the phrasing/verbage was quite weird which sent up a red flag for me. Also, “Andrea Barton” did not even bother putting a name in the salutation line.

    I am writing to know If you can tutor my daughter for 6 weeks starting from August 22, 2011. Her name is Caron, she is 14 years old ,I just don’t want her to be less busy when she arrive in your location for her holiday so I just want her to get hooked up with one thing or the other. You know what I’m talking about. It can be on Music or Dance. Let me know how much you charge per hour and let me know the total for 6 weeks lesson. You can take her on any day convenient for you for 2 hours lesson per week. You can just take her at your convenient schedule. Please tell me your past teaching experience and make up lesson. I hope to read back from you soon. Have a nice time.
    God Bless you
    Best Wishes
    Andrea Barton

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: